The Lost version, meanwhile, has one Radial, one Triangle, and one Waning slot. The reasons were as follows; 1. 280 + 143 (52/91) The next 'builds' are not builds I have in the list below, but rather they're just me playing with the numbers for you guys. Feb 16, 2019. the R2 light beams do insane dmg - 1400+ to watchers if I can connect with the sword as well --. with three nourishings it could easily be over 1000. It was added with The Old Hunters DLC. You get slightly more damage with 50 strength, while 50 skill would give you higher visceral attack damage. The Holy Moonlight Sword is Trick Weapon in Bloodborne, found in The Old Hunter's DLC. Holy Moonlight Sword vs. Best gems for the REGULAR Holy moonlight sword? Would appreciate some knowledge. 3% stamina cost increase and a nourishing 20. The HMS deals split damage in all of its attacks, so you should have a decent amount of str and skill on top of arcane for it to have optimal damage, a 25/25/50 str/skl/arc split is a good setup. If you're running a 120 build for Moonlight Sword, post it here. The Saw Cleaver will be equipped with Bolt gems, allowing for extra damage against Kin enemies. CryptoThis is different from the Holy Moonlight Sword, which scales off of all three, and can get an attack rating of over 1000. CryptoPosted by u/SpiritJuice - 2 votes and 4 commentsFandom Apps Take your favorite fandoms with you and never miss a beat. The Holy Moonlight Sword scales evenly with Strength and Dexterity, so it’s a good weapon for any Melee. Add a Comment. For physical damage, STR gives better scaling than SKL, but SKL gives more up to 25 than STR gives over 25. And my secondary weapon is just a saw spearHMS in trick form has large multipliers based on ARC and R2 and L2 attacks ONLY scale on ARC. Won't work in a statisfying manner. I got extremely lucky yesterday when farming Amygdala and I got this setup at the end of the day Link Yes that's an OOS…Holy Moonlight Sword gem specking question . 5 radial from rom (or a 19. 5%, Cold gems are way better than Flat Arcane gems in this case. Always (unless you're making a thrust version). Psn: beastlytoast. What are some good middle of the road gems that will help me at least finish the game on ng++ to. Ludwig’s Holy Blade 4. I suggest going the Arcane route, 50, and then Str 25 and Skl 15. Physical ATK up +21. 2563% droprate). On a 50/25/50 build with Nourishing gems, it can wreck shop, and it's nearly as good (though it loses the damage from the beams) on a 50/25/14 build gemmed up for pure physical. Perform ritual and defeat layer 2 bosses to obtain the Pthumeru root chalice. Description In-Game Description An arcane sword discovered long ago by Ludwig. I'm doing a 110 right now 40vit 15end 25str. It won't do quite as much damage as a dedicated physical weapon (say, Ludwig's Holy Blade), but will be highly effective nonetheless. $500 - $400 = $200 - Quincy2000a (also. ago. 6% won't beat Cold gems in this case. Simon’s Bowblade 9. They'll sell you the other versions. Stats: Vit-40 End-19 Str-20 Skill-12 Bloodtinge-5 Arcane-40. 07, are a gift from the Godhead. Nourishing blood gems are. 1. 5%, Cold gems are way better than Flat Arcane gems in this case. Nourishing gems are by far and away best for this weapon. I've been happy with all the weapons except one, which is the reason I'm making this post. The sword, which in most games takes the form of a giant blade that glows an eery green and blasts beams of light, appears in the giant mech battler Armored Core 6 as the IA. Blood Gems are 95% of the reason the Chalice Dungeons exist and are delved into. Without considering OOS gems the best possible setup is with the lost version using the Amy’s 21. 2. Since it's Arcane, I'd suggest hitting 50 Arc, at the minimum. It's essentially a strength dominant quality weapon that has several utility attacks and 2-handed damage bonuses dependent on arcane. 5% nourishing, +15 physical,. $215. Holy Moonlight. I have 20str and 78arc (35skl too since I know it slightly scales with skill as well) I noticed that it scales the most with strength but was hoping I could make up for it in high arcane levels. Most likely originating as a simple Yharnam citizen, Simon hailed from the earlier days of the Healing Church's initially glorious (and eventually. This blade was owned by Ludwig. This is only my speculation but it allows the a "Moonlight" weapon to exist in Bloodborne without. The ideal gems are Nourishing from the FRC (not the easiest to farm). You can also farm Rom for radials but it's a thousand times more tedious and the improvement is marginal at best. Do the glyph search for 8i29rqz3. Gargoyle Gem can also work well, while 19. And then you discovered the 18. Yes. 3. 3 are a much easier option than chalice Rom. I want to add the hms to my Arsenal what…25 votes, 38 comments. I wanted to use the HMS, but wasn't sure which gems went best with this awesome weapon, so I tried both Nourishing Gems, then Tempering Gems, then…Okay exactly what it says, I've been doing some research into the Holy Moonlight Sword to give it a try, my biggest question advice for how to GET to…Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. You should be able to go inside now. 2% physical, 3. 50/20/50/25/5/50 is a pretty classic BL 150 HMS build. On Holy Moonlight Sword with 99 Arcane, the first +65 Cold gem is equivalent to 32. -. 2% + 10,1% at full health gems. Best. That should be enough until you get the Moonlight. Check out the show's floor plan and the products that will be. Nourishing bloodgems is the safe bet for this weapon. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Holy Moonlight Sword: 90 / - / 50 / - / - (Blunt/Arc. 3 from the gargoyles as an alternative). What are the best gems for hms and where do i farm them comments sorted by Best Top New Controversial Q&A Add a Comment MidnightMadness09 • Additional comment actions. [deleted] • 8 yr. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. hi guys! I'm no expert on the mechanics of scaling, builds, etc. This can be used to combo enemies which normally cannot be unlocked by R1 attacks. The Holy Moonlight Sword is a Trick Weapon in Bloodborne's The Old Hunters DLC. There are 3 main Nourishing Gems you'll be looking at for this kinda. I did a Moonlight great sword build a few times, IMO, going with the physical %+ gems works best for overall damage. I’m glad you asked me this because I’ve been itching to talk about it for days! The Holy Moonlight Sword is a remarkable STR/ARC weapon. Chalice Dungeon. Regular version for quality builds and put 27. This sword starts out as a normal sword, but transformed, it turns into a giant sword made of concentrated moonlight, able to dish out Arcane damage and shoot beams of moonlight at enemies. While it’s a fantastic weapon especially at range, I want something fast that I can switch to when the Larger Greatsword is a liability in close range PvP. ARC: 33. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. 50/25/25 strength/skill/arcane is my favorite build for it. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. And some gems to change phys damage to arc damage (sorry I'm little lost in gems, can't name particular ones). 5% atk + 2nd stat abyssal gems which will drop only off of layer 3 or 4 versions of the amygdala fight in an Isz. 5% triangle gem from Amy in Isz, and then put in the radial of your choice (depending on whether the extra . I personally like the beast hunter saif gemmed with bolt, and saw spear gemmed with fire, but you can basically use almost anything as long as it can be converted. (If you're not using the Lost version, grab two radials off the gargoyles, which is easier farming than Depth 5 FRC Amy but weaker gems. There's a great post about Arcane builds, check it out here. It was already in the table too, I forgot. The Holy Moonlight Sword is a different animal. Holy moonlight sword . 3%/ATK vs beasts down -10. 3%/ATK vs kin down -10. Bloodletter 8. 280 + 196 (176/20) Mighty Magic. MLGS has two Radial Blood Gem slots and either a Triangle slot if Normal or a Waning slot if Uncanny. You need to obtain both the Pthumeru Ihyll root and the Isz root at the very least. The +Scaling gems are additive to the weapons base damage, and the math is such that there will never be an instance where three will give you more AR than 2 + a percent based gem. CryptoLudwig's Holy Blade is a Trick Weapon that is comprised of a holy longsword that can be transformed into an even greater sword when sheathed - as the sword sheath doubles as a heavier blade. Like Moonlight and Parasite, the displayed AR is misleading. The boss there should drop the "Pthumeru Root Chalice". GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Business, Economics, and Finance. Chikage 7. Can be percent-based or. There are 3 main Nourishing Gems you'll be looking at for this kinda setup: Gargoyles in FRC Ihyll for 19. Transformed charged L2 is devastating for splatting enemies on their backs. ago. If you want the very best gems you’ll need the lost version of the sword that you can buy from the messenger baths on the 3rd layer of the depth 5 dungeons, Isz, Lower Loran etc. Icing on the cake. +10 Ludwigs holy blade AR 975 (2x 27. Disclaimer: I don't want to use Nourishing Gems, it takes too much to farm and I want to enjoy my ride with the weapon, not make this a business work, even the AR is not the . I'm rolling with a Lvl 150 build, these are the stats: 40/40/50/25/5/40 Should I go with the normal version or the lost one?, also, which kind of…Making my first moonlight greatsword build in this game what is the version with the best imprints on it. These weapons can be transformed into alternate forms and have different attacks in their transformed mode. And some gems to change phys damage to arc damage (sorry I'm little lost in gems, can't name particular ones). In the DLC, defeat Ludwig and acquire the Holy Moonlight Sword. The ideal gems are Nourishing from the FRC (not the easiest to farm). Business, Economics, and Finance. 2% Stamina Cost. What’s the most optimal build and gems for an Arc/Str build that uses mainly the Holy Moonlight Sword? Advertisement Coins. Triangle: 20: 21. 3 physical gems that push it to 621 physcial. The Holy Moonlight Sword is a quality-ARC weapon. wiki. There are 3 main Nourishing Gems you'll be looking at for this. I was gonna start a…Quick to run with good bosses (Watchers for physical gems, easy Brainsucker and Amygdala). The recommended BL for NG+ is far too high. Summon Valtr, he will be your main source of damage. 2% is worth fighting boss Rom instead of just farming gargoyles). I don't usually use untransformed R1s, so I'm not sure, but the transformed R1s get low to mid 900s, roughly. When it's untransformed, while it technically has arcane scaling, it's extremely weak meaning in reality it's a quality weapon that wants both strength and skill primarily. 8i29rqz3Business, Economics, and Finance. phys AR of 737. Regardless of your intentions, the Holy Moonlight Sword is an excellent choice, and an overall excellent weapon. The Pick can use a standard physical setup or use Adept (Thrust) gems for even more damage. The Holy Moonlight Sword isn't quite as popular in the "broken weapon" set as the Saw Cleaver/Spear, Ludwig's Holy Blade, Whirligig Saw, Chikage, or Church Pick. The best Bolt gem can be found in Yahar’gul. 12x: 25 (+run) The sword is slashed from left. CryptoBest. You can then aim for STR 50 + SKL 25 and gem up the sword as if it was an ordinary physical weapon. You will have a hard time (you can’t) optimize a HMS build at 120. 27K subscribers in the tombprospectors community. So I’ve been grinding for high level cursed nourishing gems and have finally finished my perfect abyssal gem Holy Moonlight Greatsword. It deals both arcane and physical damage. More laser oriented: Nourising + Abyssal. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. You want three nourishing gems, or two nourishing and one flat arcane (or arcane scaling) depending on how you want to utilize it. Thanks!. Church Pick 10. Percent based gems affect all sources of AR: base damage, scaling bonus, and other gems. A better weapon for high level builds is probably the Moonlight Sword + nourishing gems, as it has split damage and scales with STR, SKL and ARC. Would. Anytime you pick up a new weapon in Bloodborne you will have to not only fortify and gem it to get the damage up to speed, but you'll also have to learn to use it. is the real-life alternate name for an iron meteorite, and it seems to be the reason why arcane power. That gem has "15% All Atk" on it. I finally took the plunge and I got the DLC. If you use arcane gems and blood bullets to avoid running out of quicksilver you'd do fine. Soundtrack: Ryan Amon - Hunter's DreamThe awesome wiki: you want to use holy moonlight sword i suggest you go for 25 skill,25 strength and 50 arcane because no matter it's state it does split dmg (that means it deals both physical and arcane at the same time,in 2H mode the percentage for arcane damage is increased,also it scales with all these 3 stats:skill,strength,arcane). CryptoReiderAsmadi posted. Whirligig Saw Description "A trick weapon crafted by the workshop heretics, the Powder. This makes it very effective against enemies weak to thrusts and allows the setting of powerful “adept” blood gems. Ludwig's Blade can transform from a speedy one-handed sword to a brutal two-handed greatsword. I need help trying to find good gems with this sword. Thanks. Bosses; Lore. Best runes for this build are: Clawmark. The best gems for the HMS are top tier cursed nourishing gems, which are only available after you've cleared through the majority of dungeons. The boss there should drop the "Pthumeru Root Chalice". i have the normal ver. I have the baby version of such a setup in my regular Holy Moonlight Sword—two non-Abyssal gargoyle Nourishing Radials and a Triangle from Isz Amy that I don't even think is max quality because I didn't really know how gems worked back when I got it—and. GameStop Moderna Pfizer Johnson & Johnson AstraZeneca Walgreens Best Buy Novavax SpaceX Tesla. Beat Layer 1. Business, Economics, and Finance. Reply Replies (1) 1 +1. There are 3 versions of this weapon: Normal, Uncanny and Lost. Would the uncanny or lost version be better for what I'm trying to achieve? I'm aware that they have different gem imprints but I'm really not sure what gems would be best for this weapon's trick form. Holy Moonlight Sword - Gem Help . CryptoWith a gem like that on LHB, your base damage is converted to arcane, you get bonus for the arcane scaling of your weapon, and then +65 arcane damage for the gem. fextralife. They are very effective when used to fill all 3 gem slots on the Wheel and the Tonitrus since they increase BOTH of their respective damage types and self-buffs. Didn't get one here but Amy drops them all the time. The Chikage is a Trick Weapon in Bloodborne. The Holy Moonlight Sword itself can be described as a quality weapon with a bit of arc scaling. A Blood Gem has several properties which impact its. Big_Br0wnie • 1 yr. The Normal version trades that waning slot for another radial slot. ^^. Best Gems For Holy Moonlight Sword Users. Nourishing gems are by far and away best for this weapon. These weapons can be transformed into alternate forms and have different attacks in their transformed mode. Moonlight Sword is unique in that it's actually much better on high level builds, so you're going to sacrifice on anything below 150. Exit back into the Dream and go to another altar. 280 + 143 (52/91) The next 'builds' are not builds I have in the list below, but rather they're just me playing with the numbers for you guys. I did a Moonlight great sword build a few times, IMO, going with the physical %+ gems works best for overall damage. Submit. Trivia. Nourishing gems are best, but they're limited in the base game and dlc. 2's in it, lost version for the more powerful nourishing gems if you're doing a str/arc build. 3 are a much easier option than chalice Rom. However, on a weapon that has split damage by default (eg: Blades of Mercy, Burial Blade, Holy Moonlight Sword, Tonitrus, Boom Hammer, Wheel, etc), the base damage cannot be. I personally still use Flat Arcane even with 99/99, it's a matter of preference. tl;dr Level arcane and use the transformed R2 a lot. Moonlight Greatsword is a Weapon in Dark Souls and Dark Souls Remastered. But, with the regular version you can just farm two 19. Ludwig, The Accursed is a Boss in The Old Hunters Expansion for Bloodborne. Keep it, its very good in the HMS because it increases physical and arcane damage. tl;dr Level arcane and use the transformed R2 a lot. It. When transformed, it. Their droprate is very low on Ihyll (OOE, 0. Best gems for Holy Moonlight Sword?. It has a hefty price tag of 20,000 Blood Echoes, but it is worth it. The sword I have upgraded to +10 is the normal version. Business, Economics, and Finance. 40" Full Metal Moonlight Sword From Dark Souls, Moonlight Greatsword Replica Sword inspired by Dark Souls, Dark Souls Cosplay Gift for him, (346) $105. Can be percent-based or flat damage bonus. The ideal build is 50 Str, 25 Skill, 50 Arcane. Plus, it deals more Arcane damage than Physical, so it’s great for the rare Arcane-build characters. A Caryll rune discovered by the old hunter Ludwig along with the Holy Moonlight Sword. It is part of The Old Hunters DLC. The Lost version, meanwhile, has one Radial, one Triangle, and one Waning slot. CryptoYou can be very powerful with virtually every weapon in the game, if your character is built for it. 625 likes · 3 talking about this. If you're interested in making a Strength/Arcane build. The untricked charged r2 hits for about 1300 damage. There are 3 versions of this weapon: Normal, Uncanny and Lost. Chikage Description "Foreign-made weapon wielded by the royal guards who protect Annalise, Queen of the. I dealt with Ludwig's first form on the first post grind run by using the stairs to my advantage and the. I think the best r ATK up 19 or 20% (which increases all dmg like physical and arcane, or physical and fire) with a negative effect that varysGenerally you want nourishing gems for the Holy Moonlight Sword. I am not but my shadow, though my shadow be not shadow, but myself. The Holy Moonlight GSword uses about the same amount of Physical and Arcane in both forms for damage, so having high Arcane, but low Str and Skl will ultimately put it down. The mistake a lot of people make is they get the way physical/arcane weapons work mixed up with how Bloodtinge weapons (Chikage, Bowblade, and Bloodletter) work. Considering this weapon isn't obtainable early (obviously), I was wondering what a good wepaon(s) would be to us before I get it, so my stats are…27. With 30 Str/20 Skl and some modest gems, my AR for LHB was ~360 at character level 70. They increase the damage of all attacks. The Blade of Mercy was originally named as "Warped Twinblades" during the Alpha test, and it was the tool of choice for the "agile" hunter. Ludwig's Holy Blade is a Trick Weapon in Bloodborne. Using Nourishing gems will raise both the physical and arcane damage and maximize. Underground Corpse Pile: Found on Ludwig's head after the fight against him. SL 111 (ish) VIT 40 End 40 STR 30 Skil 37 Bld (minimum) Arc (minimum). r/bloodborne A chip A close button A chip A close buttonBlood Gems. channels the abyssal cosmos, its great blade will hurl a. The Saw Cleaver will be equipped with Bolt gems, allowing for extra damage against Kin enemies. Beating Every Souls Game with THE Moonlight Greatsword 3 months ago Bloodborne | Blood Gem Guide: Physical Damage Les Webster BloodborneGargoyle Gem can also work well, while 19. I’m currently using one Radial +27. Some of those gems are difficult to farm though. Pick up the fire gem in Cathedral ward and use it on this weapon. Gargoyles drop. Though STR scales higher than SKL so it's better to stack it. For example, the untricked R2/charged R2 have a 1. Yes. Gems for moonlight are physical ATK up +22. That's noteworthy since it breaks the pattern and these are weapons with bloodtinge scaling (in. Arcane is not as effective as you might think and not all attacks deal arcane. An arcane sword discovered long ago by Ludwig. 1phys/+13. You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Glyph is r. 3% stamina cost) +10 Moonlight sword AR 996 (2x 26. With this new gem the weapon scaled off arcane (weapon cap is 40, tools are 99, as far as I know anyway) and I was able to farm a second +22% arcane gem, this time with increased stamina use 3%, which I didn't even notice a difference with the stamina. It has an enormous multiplier, is highly spammable, and deals thrust damage. The Healing church workshop began with Ludwig, and departed from old Gehrman's technique to provide hunters with the means to fight more terrifying beasts, and perhaps things still worse. MLGS has two Radial Blood Gem slots and either a Triangle slot if Normal or a Waning slot if Uncanny. It deals cumulative damage from the beams and melee moveset with combined hits. CryptoLost would be best to benefit from Nourishing gems, which increase both physical and arcane attack. You can then farm a +21. 120 build: 45-20-25-25-5-50 - Gems in the HMLS are at the end of the video and here:20% A. A rather dull-looking one-handed sword that can transform into a glowing two-handed greatsword, the Holy Moonlight Sword is the perfect weapon for hunters wanting to. Wanting to switch to the holy moonlight sword, but currently in a quality build. Im looking for gems to help me optimize the swords damage, all the guides and builds I can find always go for optimal gems with 30+ hours of farming. So both attacks (normal and power attacks) will scale only from arcane. Business, Economics, and Finance. The most up-to-date information about vendors, news, and weather for the Victoria Gem & Mineral Show by CanGems. Ludwig's Holy Blade is a Trick Weapon in Bloodborne. You get slightly more damage with 50 strength, while 50 skill would give you higher visceral attack damage. Maps. 3% atk up). For now I see 2 variants: 1. The regular version with 2x Radial Slots and 1x Triangular Slot is fine and you can even find an early Nourishing Gem in the cave that connects the Forbidden Woods to Iosefka's Clinic (plus a Nourishing Radial later in Mensis near the two Boars). The worst way to use the Holy Moonlight Sword is on a pure Arcane build. I decided to make a STR / ARC build with HMS as main weapon (using both form). However the easier gems to farm would be Normal Holy Moonlight Sword with 2 radials from the pwmf22gu gargoyles. 3% physical, 3. . If you miss the head, return to the arena and look for Simon the Harrowed, who. Sorry for the brief messages. Imprints (Lost) Amygdalan Arm is a Trick Weapon in Bloodborne. The saw cleaver. Dark Souls 2 and 3 had tons of weapons, but way too much moveset copies. I need your advice about build for Holy Moonlight Sword. For HMLGS the order of things to skill is: 25 Str > 25 Arc > 50 Str = 25 Skl > 50 Arc > 50 Skl. It's essentially a strength dominant quality weapon that has several utility attacks and 2-handed damage bonuses dependent on arcane. Even the second one is equivalent to 24. Pizza cutter/moonlight sword/boom hammer. You will have to focus on either physical damage or arcane. I also still feel like I'm doing really low damage with not just the Holy Moonlight Sword but also the Ludwig's Holy Blade which does 600 damage. I usually see about 2,050 on the transformed to untransformed L1 attack. Business, Economics, and Finance. Oct 25, 2017. These gems really shine on the moonlight sword and boomhammer. The ideal build is 50 Str, 25 Skill, 50 Arcane. I keep looking up builds but it doesnt make sense there are so many that run seemingly weak gems. Normal Uncanny Or Lost Here's the wiki page…The Holy Moonlight Blade helped propagate the myth of Ludwig, the Holy Blade, due to how sparingly he used its beautiful moonlit state. I know tier lists have been done to death, but I just started playing Bloodborne recently. Always go more bloodvile rune over bullets, it works out much better, 1 bloodvile = 5 bullets. 99 Arcane KP with Milkweed max Arcane Gems and L4 one shots just about any non-boss, including other players. It requires 16 strength, 12 skill and 14 arcane of its wielder. The gems are essential in my HMS build but the issue is other weapons with equally beneficial gem set-ups still vastly underperform the HMS. The Holy Moonlight Sword is far from a pure arcane weapon. Then pick up Ludwig's Holy Blade (physical) as backup for fire-resistant things or thrust-weak enemies. Radial gems are significantly easier to farm for since you can farm D5 FRC gargoyle mobs for them. Even with them my Ludwigs Sword with full fire/bolt gems was just plain better for pure damage and bolt gems are especially easy to get witn Old Hunters DLC. Still also a good and fun to use weapon. I also still feel like I'm doing really low. Total: 423. When I’m specking the gems in it, should I focus on physical attack, arcane, or a balance of both? I haven’t really used anything arcane during my play through (Blood Level 142) and I don’t know which is better between that. Blood Gems are 95% of the reason the Chalice Dungeons exist and are delved into. com I recently obtained the holy moonlight sword from Ludwig and I have gotten it up to +10 and gemmed it up and it only does 599 damage. I have a fire gemmed Saw Cleaver and a lightning gemmed LHB ready to swap depending on what works better. 3% stamina cost) +10 Moonlight sword AR 996 (2x 26. 5% atk + 15 phys : Dropped by Rom, the Vacuous Spider: v5v5fpsd, F/R/C Ihyll L3: Lost Holy Moonlight S. It was introduced in The Old Hunters Expansion. 28 (51% off) FREE shipping. The moonlight sword is obviously going to be longer but I will get there eventually. Im lost on the split damage for gems. This option requires nourishing gems to work. It has one of if not the best uncharged R2 in the game. It is said that the silver sword was employed by Ludwig, the first hunter of the church. 4,595. Always (unless you're making a thrust version). Best.